BigCapital 测试版

文章 · 经济

民主与经济增长:二者有关联吗?

1950年以来,整整十年都是民主政体的经济体,人均GDP每年增长的中位数为2.2%;整整十年都是非民主政体的经济体则为2.0%。平均数很接近。离散程度则不然:最快的15个十年期中有11个来自非民主国家,最差的15个中有15个。

Maddison Project 2023与Boix–Miller–Rosato 4.0 · 数据截至2020阅读约4分钟

人均每年的典型增长,1950–2020
2.2% 对 2.0%

十年期中位数:民主国家与非民主国家(301个和386个十年期)

十年期增长的离散程度
×2.0

标准差:非民主国家为3.6个百分点,民主国家为1.8

最快的15个国家十年期
15中的11

整个十年都处于非民主政体;这类十年期占全部的48%

最差的15个国家十年期
15中的15

整个十年都处于非民主政体;最低的一个,人均收入每年下降11.7%

民主政体一年内崩溃的概率
8.2% → 0.1%

人均低于$2,000与高于$20,000对比(1,112个国家年中有1民主崩溃),1950–2020

比较的方法

两个公开数据集,按国家和年份逐一对应。政体来自Boix–Miller–Rosato编码(版本4.0),它把1800年至2020年每一年的每个主权国家标记为民主或非民主。同时满足以下三个条件的国家年,算作民主政体:

  1. 行政首脑通过全民选举直接或间接产生,并对选民或立法机构负责;
  2. 立法机构(或直接选举产生的行政首脑)通过自由公正的选举产生;
  3. 多数成年男性享有选举权。

收入是Maddison Project(2023版)的人均GDP,以2011年国际元计:已经扣除通胀以及国家之间的价格差异。比较的单位是国家十年期:从1950年到1960年的增长,依此类推,直到2010–2020。某个十年,如果该国十年中每一年都被编码为民主,就属于民主政体;如果每一年都被编码为非民主,就属于非民主政体;其余情况为“有变更”。期初人口少于1百万的经济体不计入。最终得到来自152个经济体的811个国家十年期:民主301个,非民主386个,有政体更替的124个。

“非民主”是数据集自己的分类;日常用语中,这类政体大多被称为专制或威权政体。这一编码只是对领导人产生方式的最简二元记录,并不评判任何人治理得好坏。本文按原样报告数据,对任何政府,无论过去还是现在,都不持立场。

平均而言,两组的增长速度相近

在301个民主十年期中,人均GDP增长的中位数为每年2.2%,平均数为2.4%;在386个非民主十年期中,中位数为2.0%,平均数为2.0%。民主国家的中位数更高。平均数之差为每年0.3个百分点,民主国家占优,小于其统计误差范围(±0.4个百分点):就这一简单比较而言,两组无法区分。

两者的差别就在离散程度。民主十年期中居中的一半,增长在每年+1.2%到+3.3%之间;非民主十年期中居中的一半,在+0.2%到+3.9%之间。非民主十年期中最弱的十分之一人均收入每年下降超过1.7%;民主十年期中最弱的十分之一每年增长不足+0.5%。衡量离散程度的常用指标标准差,非民主国家为3.6个百分点,民主国家为1.8:×2.0。

民主非民主十年内发生变更
每个点代表一个国家十年期:人均GDP每年的增长,以2011年美元计。箱体:居中的一半;须线:第10至第90百分位;线:中位数。人口至少1百万的经济体。 数据:Maddison Project Database 2023(Bolt和van Zanden),CC BY 4.0 · 原始数据来源 · 计算:BigCapital 政体:Boix–Miller–Rosato民主二分编码,版本4.0(CC0 1.0)
十年内的政体十年期数每年中位数平均数第10至第90百分位标准差,百分点每年6%或以上收入下降
民主301+2.2%+2.4%+0.5% … +4.4%1.83%6%
非民主386+2.0%+2.0%−1.7% … +6.3%3.611%23%
十年内发生变更124+1.8%+1.6%−1.5% … +4.2%2.54%25%

逐年来看,规律相同。在8,331个没有政体更替的国家年中,人均GDP下降超过5%的,占非民主年份的8.5%、民主年份的4.2%;增长超过10%的,分别占6.5%和2.1%。年度增长的标准差:7.0个百分点对4.0。

最快和最差的十年期,大多来自同一组

把全部811个国家十年期按增长排序。最快的15个中,有11个处于非民主政体, 3个处于民主政体和1个有政体更替。最差的15个中:15个处于非民主政体,全部如此。非民主国家占全部十年期的48%,因此它们在两端出现的频率高于其占比本身所能解释的程度。

达到奇迹速度的十年期,即每年6%或以上(我们“经济奇迹”文章的标准):非民主国家386个中有43个(11%),民主国家301个中有8个(3%)。人均收入下降的十年期:非民主90个(23%),民主19个(6%)。全部范围为:非民主政体下每年−11.7%到+17.4%,民主政体下为−3.3%到+10.3%。

民主非民主十年内发生变更
每个十年期人均GDP每年的增长;颜色:该十年的政体编码。人口至少1百万的经济体,1950–2020。 数据:Maddison Project Database 2023(Bolt和van Zanden),CC BY 4.0 · 原始数据来源 · 计算:BigCapital 政体:Boix–Miller–Rosato民主二分编码,版本4.0(CC0 1.0)
最快的15个和最差的15个十年期(表格)
最快的15个
#经济体年份跨度每年政体编码
1利比亚1960–1970+17.4% 非民主
2阿塞拜疆2000–2010+14.4% 非民主
3安哥拉2000–2010+14.1% 非民主
4科威特1990–2000+13.9% 非民主
5土库曼斯坦2000–2010+13.2% 非民主
6阿富汗2000–2010+12.5% 非民主
7利比亚2000–2010+11.6% 非民主
8伊拉克2000–2010+10.9% 非民主
9蒙古2000–2010+10.3% 民主
10日本1960–1970+9.3% 民主
11乍得2000–2010+9.2% 非民主
12黎巴嫩1990–2000+9.1% 非民主
13阿曼1990–2000+8.9% 非民主
14罗马尼亚2000–2010+8.7% 民主
15韩国1980–1990+8.6% 十年内发生变更
最差的15个
#经济体年份跨度每年政体编码
1委内瑞拉2010–2020−11.7% 非民主
2伊拉克1980–1990−9.1% 非民主
3利比亚2010–2020−8.7% 非民主
4利比里亚1980–1990−8.6% 非民主
5也门2010–2020−8.3% 非民主
6叙利亚2010–2020−7.8% 非民主
7科威特1980–1990−7.4% 非民主
8阿拉伯联合酋长国1980–1990−6.6% 非民主
9塞拉利昂1990–2000−6.6% 非民主
10刚果(金)1990–2000−6.5% 非民主
11阿富汗1990–2000−6.3% 非民主
12利比亚1980–1990−5.6% 非民主
13利比里亚1990–2000−5.4% 非民主
14津巴布韦2000–2010−4.5% 非民主
15科特迪瓦1980–1990−4.4% 非民主

两端的许多案例是石油经济体、战争以及战后反弹:这些因素无论政体如何都会推动收入变化。研究者也发现了同样的形态:Almeida和Ferreira(2002)报告称,增长表现最好和最差的国家,都更可能是专制国家。

差距的正负逐个十年期变化

按十年期拆分,中位数互有胜负:民主国家在7个十年中的4个(1960–1970, 1970–1980, 1980–1990和1990–2000)增长更快,非民主国家在3个(1950–1960, 2000–2010和2010–2020)增长更快。差距最大的是1980–1990,每年2.0个百分点,民主国家占优。

民主国家的起点也更富:民主十年期的中位数起始于人均$13,209,非民主十年期的中位数起始于$2,558。更富裕的经济体通常增长更慢,因为它们无法靠模仿别处已经行之有效的做法来追赶,所以原始的比较是有偏的。在三个等大的收入区间内进行同类对比:低于$2,500,1.8%对1.2%(26个和192个十年期); $2,500–$8,700,3.2%对3.1%(77个和140个十年期); 高于$8,700,2.1%对1.4%(198个和54个十年期)。在全部3个区间中,民主国家的中位数都更高。

民主非民主
人均GDP每年增长的中位数,十年中每一年都被编码为民主或非民主的国家十年期。收入区间:按期初人均GDP(以2011年美元计)把全部十年期分成三等份。 数据:Maddison Project Database 2023(Bolt和van Zanden),CC BY 4.0 · 原始数据来源 · 计算:BigCapital 政体:Boix–Miller–Rosato民主二分编码,版本4.0(CC0 1.0)
各十年期的中位数(表格)
年份跨度民主非民主
1950–1960+2.4% 25+2.8% 31
1960–1970+3.5% 26+2.4% 55
1970–1980+2.7% 24+2.3% 69
1980–1990+1.8% 29−0.2% 66
1990–2000+2.4% 52+1.7% 52
2000–2010+2.7% 70+4.4% 57
2010–2020+1.2% 75+1.3% 56

每个中位数之后:该组的国家十年期数。

政体更替时收入会怎样

1961年至2001年间,有63次向民主的转变和41次民主崩溃,具有变更前10年至变更后20年的收入数据(人口至少1百万的经济体)。图表追踪人均GDP相对同年平均经济体的表现,因此全球性的繁荣或萧条不计入,并把变更前一年设为零。

向民主的转变。在此前10年中,这些国家与平均经济体持平;在最后5年中,它们落后平均经济体2.5%,在误差范围之内。最低点出现在变更后5 年:−3.2%(95%区间−8.3%至+2.1%),在误差范围之内。20年后,它们处于−1.1%(−10.6%至+9.3%),在误差范围之内。63个中有33个在20年后或在2020年仍被编码为民主国家。

民主崩溃。在此前10年中,这些国家落后平均经济体6.3%,在误差范围之外;在最后5年中,它们落后平均经济体2.7%,在误差范围之内。最低点出现在变更后1 年:−4.8%(−7.3%至−2.3%),在误差范围之外。20年后:+5.7%(−5.3%至+18.0%),在误差范围之内。

向民主的转变民主崩溃95%区间
人均GDP相对样本平均经济体的表现,与变更前一年(0)比较。线:各事件的平均;阴影:95%区间。变更依Boix、Miller和Rosato的编码;变更前10年至变更后20年。 数据:Maddison Project Database 2023(Bolt和van Zanden),CC BY 4.0 · 原始数据来源 · 计算:BigCapital 政体:Boix–Miller–Rosato民主二分编码,版本4.0(CC0 1.0)
图表背后的数字
年份向民主的转变民主崩溃
第−10年+0.3%−5.3% … +6.3%+6.7%+0.5% … +13.3%
第−5年+2.6%−0.9% … +6.3%+2.8%−0.7% … +6.4%
第−1年00
第0年−0.8%−2.0% … +0.3%−4.2%−8.3% … +0.1%
第+1年−0.7%−2.6% … +1.3%−4.8%−7.3% … −2.3%
第+2年−0.3%−2.8% … +2.2%−4.5%−7.9% … −1.0%
第+5年−3.2%−8.3% … +2.1%−2.0%−6.7% … +3.0%
第+10年−1.2%−7.5% … +5.5%−0.5%−7.1% … +6.5%
第+15年+1.4%−6.4% … +10.0%+1.5%−7.7% … +11.5%
第+20年−1.1%−10.6% … +9.3%+5.7%−5.3% … +18.0%

自变更前一年以来,人均GDP相对平均经济体的变化;小字:95%区间。63次转变和41次崩溃。

平均而言,两类变更都发生在落后于平均经济体的若干年之后,不过对向民主的转变而言,这一下滑在误差范围之内:增长可以塑造政体,而不只是反过来。严谨的研究不止于求平均。Acemoglu、Naidu、Restrepo和Robinson(2019)为每个国家自身的增长路径建模,包括他们发现的民主化之前的下滑,并估计“民主化使人均GDP在长期内提高约20%”。像上面这样的简单平均,并不适合区分原因与结果,其很宽的区间也说明各个案例差别很大。

越富裕的国家越常是民主国家

把问题反过来看。在1950年至2020年的全部国家年中,被编码为民主的占比在人均低于$2,000时随收入上升:15%,在$20,000–$40,000时升至87%,人均高于$40,000时为68%。2020年,人均高于$20,000的48个经济体中有37个是民主国家,人均低于$2,000的21个中有6个。在此期间,民主国家的数量从1950年68个经济体中的29个,增加到2020年150个中的84个。

民主非民主
每个方块代表一个人口至少1百万的经济体,按人均GDP(以2011年美元计)排列,并按当年的编码着色;每列上方为其中的民主国家数。 数据:Maddison Project Database 2023(Bolt和van Zanden),CC BY 4.0 · 原始数据来源 · 计算:BigCapital 政体:Boix–Miller–Rosato民主二分编码,版本4.0(CC0 1.0)

这种关联主要通过存续体现出来。人均低于$2,000的民主国家,在8.2%的年份里发生崩溃(318个国家年中有26次);人均高于$20,000的,为0.1%(1,112个国家年中有1次民主崩溃)。非民主国家一年内转变为民主国家的概率保持在较窄的范围内:各区间为0%到3.7%,而民主崩溃为0%到8.2%。Przeworski及其合作者(2000)描述过这一模式:民主国家在许多收入水平上都会出现,但在富裕国家持续的概率要高得多。

民主政体崩溃非民主国家转变为民主国家
按第一年的人均GDP(2011年美元)划分,民主国家下一年被编码为非民主、或非民主国家下一年被编码为民主的年度概率。国家年1950–2020,人口至少1百万的经济体。 数据:Maddison Project Database 2023(Bolt和van Zanden),CC BY 4.0 · 原始数据来源 · 计算:BigCapital 政体:Boix–Miller–Rosato民主二分编码,版本4.0(CC0 1.0)
人均GDP民主占比每年崩溃率每年转变率
低于$2,00015%8.2%26 / 3181.6%30 / 1,849
$2,000–$5,00029%4.2%23 / 5452.2%30 / 1,347
$5,000–$10,00044%2.0%15 / 7422.7%25 / 938
$10,000–$20,00070%0.5%5 / 1,0003.7%16 / 430
$20,000–$40,00087%0.1%1 / 9140.8%1 / 130
高于$40,00068%0%0 / 1980%0 / 93

收入是否导致民主,本身就有争议。Lipset(1959)提出,经济发展有利于民主。Acemoglu、Johnson、Robinson和Yared(2008)发现,当每个国家只与自身的不同时期比较时,这种统计关联就消失了。构建本文所用编码的Boix、Miller和Rosato(2013)则发现,经济现代化与民主之间的相关性已随时间减弱。

研究的发现

几十年来的研究,数据和方法各不相同,得出的答案也不同。按发表顺序简述如下:

  1. 1959

    收入 → 民主发展支持民主

    Lipset(1959),“Some Social Requisites of Democracy: Economic Development and Political Legitimacy”,American Political Science Review 53(1): 69–105。现代化理论:更富裕、受教育程度更高的社会,更可能维持民主。

  2. 1996

    民主 → 增长略为负面

    Barro(1996),“Democracy and Growth”,Journal of Economic Growth 1(1): 1–27。约100个国家,1960–1990年:在法治、自由市场、政府消费和教育水平保持不变的情况下,民主对增长的总体影响很小且略为负面,并略有曲线的迹象:政治自由度较低时,更多自由有助于增长,达到中等水平后则会拖慢增长。

  3. 2000

    民主 → 增长对总收入没有差异

    Przeworski、Alvarez、Cheibub和Limongi(2000),Democracy and Development: Political Institutions and Well-Being in the World, 1950–1990,Cambridge University Press。政体类型对总收入的增长没有影响;民主国家人均收入增长更快,是因为独裁国家人口增长更快;富裕国家的民主政体存续的可能性要大得多。

  4. 2002

    增长的稳定性专制下更高

    Almeida和Ferreira(2002),“Democracy and the Variability of Economic Performance”,Economics & Politics 14(3): 225–257。无论是在国家之间还是国家内部,专制政体下增长的波动更大;表现最好和最差的国家,都更可能是专制国家。

  5. 2008

    收入 → 民主国家内部关联消失

    Acemoglu、Johnson、Robinson和Yared(2008),“Income and Democracy”,American Economic Review 98(3): 808–842。加入国家固定效应、即每个国家只与自身比较时,从收入到民主的统计关联消失了。

  6. 2008

    民主 → 增长无直接影响,间接为正

    Doucouliagos和Ulubaşoğlu(2008),“Democracy and Economic Growth: A Meta-Analysis”,American Journal of Political Science 52(1): 61–83。汇总84项研究的483个估计:民主对增长没有直接影响,但通过更多的人力资本、更低的通胀、更高的政治稳定性和更多的经济自由,产生正面的间接影响。

  7. 2013

    收入 → 民主关联随时间减弱

    Boix、Miller和Rosato(2013),“A Complete Data Set of Political Regimes, 1800–2007”,Comparative Political Studies 46(12): 1523–1554。本页所用的编码;作者还发现,经济现代化与民主的相关性随时间减弱。

  8. 2019

    民主 → 增长长期约+20%

    Acemoglu、Naidu、Restrepo和Robinson(2019),“Democracy Does Cause Growth”,Journal of Political Economy 127(1): 47–100。采用巩固民主指标的动态面板:民主化使人均GDP在长期内提高约五分之一,途径是更多的投资、教育和健康,且在不同发展水平上的效果相近。

  9. 2022

    测量专制国家夸大增长

    Martinez(2022),“How Much Should We Trust the Dictator's GDP Growth Estimates?”,Journal of Political Economy 130(10): 2731–2769。通过比较公布的GDP与卫星观测到的夜间灯光,估计专制国家每年的GDP增长被夸大了大约三分之一(约35%)。

为什么数据无法判出胜负

平均数的比较只能描述,不能证明。阅读上述数字时需要谨慎,原因有六:

  • 因果双向。经济困难可能推翻政府(上述民主崩溃,平均而言发生在这些国家落后之后),因此政体与增长的同步变化,原因是双向的。
  • 两组的起点不同。民主十年期的中位数起始于人均$13,209,非民主十年期的中位数起始于$2,558;更富裕的经济体往往增长更慢,较穷的经济体追赶的空间更大。
  • 其他因素。石油等自然资源、战争、地理、教育和贸易都会影响增长,其中有几项也会塑造政体。
  • 测量。专制国家公布的GDP可能被夸大(Martinez 2022),这会美化它们的平均数。二元编码无法区分一党制国家与君主制或军事统治,也无法区分新民主国家与老民主国家。
  • 谁换了组别。有政体更替的十年期归入第三组(124个十年期,中位数每年1.8%),而崩溃往往会带来政体更替,因此两类政体中一些最差的结果被归到了那里。
  • 样本在变化。民主国家在1950年占68个经济体中的29个,在2020年占150个中的84个,因此民主组偏向较晚的十年期,那时世界经济的增速有所不同。

常见问题

民主国家比专制国家增长更快吗?

就简单的平均数比较而言,差距很小或没有差距。1950年以来,民主十年期人均每年增长的中位数为2.2%,非民主十年期为2.0%;平均数分别为2.4%和2.0%。平均数之差为每年0.3个百分点,民主国家占优,小于其统计误差范围(±0.4个百分点):就这一简单比较而言,两组无法区分。方法更严谨的研究得出了不同的结论:Barro(1996)发现有较小的负面影响,一项涵盖84项研究的元分析发现没有直接影响(Doucouliagos和Ulubaşoğlu 2008),而Acemoglu、Naidu、Restrepo和Robinson(2019)估计,民主化之后人均GDP的长期增益约为20%。

专制国家能快速增长吗?

是的,而且也可能快速萎缩。1950年以来最快的15个国家十年期中,有11个整个十年都处于非民主政体;最差的15个中有15个也是如此。有43个非民主十年期每年增长6%或以上,民主十年期为8个;有90个非民主十年期结束时比开始时更穷,民主十年期为19个。在这些数据中,非民主政体意味着结果的范围更宽,而不是平均水平更高。 最快的15个中的民主国家:蒙古 (2000–2010, +10.3%), 日本 (1960–1970, +9.3%)和罗马尼亚 (2000–2010, +8.7%)。

是民主带来增长,还是增长带来民主?

两个方向都有人研究,证据存在争议。越富裕的国家越常是民主国家(人均低于$2,000的国家年占15%,在$20,000–$40,000时为87%),而民主国家一旦富裕就很少崩溃(人均高于$20,000时每年0.1%)。Lipset(1959)认为发展支持民主;Acemoglu、Johnson、Robinson和Yared(2008)发现,当国家与自身不同时期比较时,这种关联就消失了;Acemoglu、Naidu、Restrepo和Robinson(2019)发现的是另一个方向,即民主促进增长。本页的平均数无法对此做出定论。

哪种政治制度最有利于经济?

数据无法给出定论。平均增长很接近;非民主政体下的增长离散程度要高得多,奇迹更多,崩溃也更多;而且研究对因果关系看法不一。证据确实表明的是:民主政体下的极端情形更少见(十年期增长的标准差为1.8个百分点,对比3.6),民主政体在富裕国家要高得多持久,专制国家公布的增长数据可能被夸大。此外,增长只是人们对政治制度的诸多期望之一。

深入了解

数字是如何计算的

  • 政体:Boix-Miller-Rosato Dichotomous Coding of Democracy,1800–2020,版本4.0,作者Michael Miller、Carles Boix和Sebastian Rosato,Harvard Dataverse,已进入公有领域(CC0 1.0)。引用:Carles Boix, Michael K. Miller, and Sebastian Rosato. 2013. "A Complete Data Set of Political Regimes, 1800-2007." Comparative Political Studies 46(12): 1523-54. doi:10.1177/0010414012463905。我们使用其主要变量democracy;分组、比率和区间是BigCapital的计算结果。
  • 收入:Maddison Project Database,版本2023,作者Jutta Bolt和Jan Luiten van Zanden(格罗宁根大学格罗宁根增长与发展中心),依据CC BY 4.0授权。引用:MPD version 2023: Bolt, Jutta and Jan Luiten van Zanden (2024). Maddison style estimates of the evolution of the world economy: A new 2023 update. Journal of Economic Surveys, 1–41,doi:10.1111/joes.12618;另见这些估计的原始数据来源。
  • 十年期:从第一年到之后第十年的人均GDP增长,以年复合增长率计;十年期的政体取自其十个增长年份的编码。期初人口至少1百万的经济体。中位数和百分位均基于国家十年期。平均数之差的误差范围为1.96个标准误,把各十年期视为相互独立;实际并不完全独立,所以这个范围若有偏差,也只会偏窄。
  • 转变与崩溃:编码从0变为1或从1变为0的年份,1961–2001,具有变更前10年至变更后20年的收入数据。每一年的增长减去该年样本中所有经济体的平均增长(取对数,每个经济体权重相等),从变更前一年起累加,再对各事件取平均。95%区间:各事件均值±1.96个标准误。后来又逆转的变更仍保留在内。
  • 收入区间:人均GDP,以2011年国际元计。崩溃率和转变率:民主(非民主)国家年之后紧接着是非民主(民主)年份的占比,按两年中第一年的收入划分。
  • 苏联、南斯拉夫和捷克斯洛伐克在解体前各按一个经济体计算,解体后按其继承国计算;跨越解体的十年期和时间窗口不计入。西德和东德、北越和南越、北也门和南也门在政体数据中分别编码,而收入数据涵盖的是今天的国家,因此这些年份不计入。政体数据截至2020年,收入数据截至2022年。
  • 政体只按公开发布的编码分类。本文不提及任何领导人或政党,也不对任何政府,无论过去还是现在,作出评判。
  • 经济史,不是预测,也不是投资建议。
收入估计的原始数据来源

Maddison Project要求,在图表中展示其数据时,须引用所有原始论文。以下是数据库列出的来源:先是2013年以来新增的来源,然后是Angus Maddison本人的来源(2010)。

2013年以来新增的来源

  • GDP pc: 2008 - 2022: Total Economy Database the Conference Board for all countries included in TED. Otherwise UN national accounts statistics
  • Population sources
  • 1990 onward Total Economy Database the Conference Board for all countries included in TED. Otherwise UN national accounts statistics
  • Argentina — 1800 - 1870: Prados de la Escosura, L. (2009). “Lost Decades? Economic Performance in Post-Independence Latin America,” Journal of Latin America Studies 41: 279–307 (updated data); 1870 - 1900: Bertola, L and Ocampo, J.A. (2012) The Economic Development of Latin America since Independence. Oxford, Oxford U.P
  • Belgium — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 1500- 1846: Buyst, E. (2011), “Towards Estimates of Long Term Growth in the Southern Low Countries, ca.1500-1846”, Results presented at the Conference on Quantifying Long Run Economic Development, Venice, 22-24 March, 2011
  • Bulgaria — 1892-1945: Ivanov, M. (2006). “Bulgarian National Income between 1892 and 1924,” Bulgarian National Discussion Papers DP/54/2006
  • Bosnia and Herzegovina — 1952-2008: Milanovic (2011). Estimates provided to the Maddison-Project
  • Bolivia (Plurinational State of) — 1846-1950: Herranz-Loncán, A. and Peres-Cajías (2016). “Bolivian GDP per capita since the mid-nineteenth century” Cliometrica 10: 99-128
  • Brazil — 1800 - 1870: Prados de la Escosura, L. (2009). “Lost Decades? Economic Performance in Post-Independence Latin America,” Journal of Latin America Studies 41: 279–307 (updated data); 1850–1899: Barro, R.J. and J.F. Ursua, (2008). “Macroeconomic Crises since 1870” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Economic Studies Program, The Brookings Institution, vol. 39(1 (Spring), pages 255-350
  • Switzerland — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 1850-2011: Stohr, Christian (2016), Trading Gains: new estimates of Swiss GDP, 1851-2008. Economic History Working Papers, 245/2016. London School of Economics and Political Science, Economic History Department, London, UK
  • Chile — 1810–2004: Díaz, J.B. Lüders, R. and Wagner, G. (2007) Economia Chilena 1810 - 2000, Producto total y sectorial una nueva mirada, Pontificia universidad Catolica de Chile, Insituto de Economia, Documeno de Trabajo no. 315
  • China — 1000-1661: Broadberry, S.N., Guan, Hanhui and David Daokui Li (2018), “China, Europe and the Great Divergence: a Study in Historical National Accounting, 980-1850”, Journal of Economic History, 78, 4, 955-1000; 1661–1933: Broadberry, S.N., Guan, Hanhui and David Daokui Li (2018), “China, Europe and the Great Divergence: a Study in Historical National Accounting, 980-1850”, Journal of Economic History, 78, 4, 955-1000; 1661–1933: Xu, Y. Z. Shi, B. van Leeuwen, Y Ni, Z Zhang, and Y Ma, (2016) 'Chinese National Income, ca. 1661-1933', Australian Economic History Review 57(3), 368–393; 1952–2008: Wu, Harry X. (2014), “China’s growth and productivity performance debate revisited – Accounting for China’s sources of growth with a new data set” The Conference Board Economics Program Working Paper Series EWP#14-01.
  • Colombia — 1800 - 1870: Prados de la Escosura, L. (2009). “Lost Decades? Economic Performance in Post-Independence Latin America,” Journal of Latin America Studies 41: 279–307 (updated data); 1870 - 1923: Bertola, L and Ocampo, J.A. (2012) The Economic Development of Latin America since Independence. Oxford, Oxford U.P.
  • Czechoslovakia — 1993 -: Based on GDP and population data for their successor states
  • Cuba — 1690–1895: Santamaria Garcia, A. (2005). Las Cuentas nacionales de Cuba, 1960 - 2005', mimeo; 1902–1958: Ward, M. and Devereux, J. (2012), “The Road Not Taken: Pre-Revolutionary Cuban Living Standards in Comparative Perspective” Journal of Economic History, 72(1): 104–132
  • Germany — 1500-1850: Pfister, U. (2022). Economic Growth in Germany, 1500–1850. The Journal of Economic History, 82(4), 1071–1107
  • Ecuador — 1833-1938: Prados de la Escosura, L. (2009). “Lost Decades? Economic Performance in Post-Independence Latin America,” Journal of Latin America Studies 41: 279–307. (updated data). We use the growth rate between 1933 and 1938 from Prados de la Escosura (2009) and link that to the 1939 level of Maddison’s original estimates.
  • Egypt — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 700 – 1500: Pamuk, Ş. and M. Shatzmiller (2011). “Real Wages and GDP per capita in the Medieval Islamic Middle East in Comparative Perspective, 700-1500”, paper presented at the 9th Conference of the European Historical Economics Society, Dublin, September 2-3, 2011.; 1820, 1870, 1913, 1950: Pamuk, S. (2006), Estimating Economic Growth in the Middle East since 1820, The Journal of Economic History, vol 66, no. 3, pp. 809 - 828
  • Spain — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 1270-1850: Álvarez-Nogal, C. and L. Prados de la Escosura (2013). "The Rise and Fall of Spain (1270-1850)," Economic History Review, 66, 1, 1-37, using their annual benchmarks; 1850–2011: Prados de la Escosura, L. (2017), Spanish Economic Growth, 1850-2015 (London: Palgrave Macmillan)
  • Finland — 1600–1860: Eloranta, J., Voutilainen, M. and Nummela, I. (2016). “Estimating Finnish Economic Growth Before 1860” mimeo.
  • France — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 1276–1800: Ridolfi, L., & Nuvolari, A. (2021). L’histoire immobile? A reappraisal of French economic growth using the demand-side approach, 1280–1850. European Review of Economic History, 25(3), 405–428
  • United Kingdom — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 1252–1700 (England): Broadberry, S.N., B. Campbell, A. Klein, M. Overton and B. van Leeuwen (2015), British Economic Growth 1270-1870 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.; 1700–1870: Broadberry, S.N., B. Campbell, A. Klein, M. Overton and B. van Leeuwen (2015), British Economic Growth 1270-1870 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  • Ghana — 1885-1950: Broadberry, S., & Gardner, L. (2022). Economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa, 1885–2008: Evidence from eight countries. Explorations in Economic History, 83, 101424.
  • Greece — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 1833-1913: Kostelenos G., S. Petmezas, D. Vasiliou, E. Kounaris and M. Sfakianakis, (2007), "Gross Domestic Product 1830-1939", Sources of Economic History of Modern Greece: Quantitative data and statistical series 1830-1939, Historical Archives of the National Bank of Greece, Athens.
  • Croatia — 1952-2008: Milanovic (2011). Estimates provided to the Maddison-Project
  • Indonesia — 1815 – 1880 (Java): Van Zanden (2012). “Economic Growth in Java 1815-1939: The Reconstruction of the Historical National Accounts of a Colonial Economy”, Maddison-Project Working Paper WP-3.; 1880-2008: Van der Eng, P. (2010). The Sources of Long-Term Economic Growth in Indonesia, 1880-2008”, Explorations in Economic History, 47: 294-309
  • India — 1600–1870: Broadberry, S.N., Custodis, J. and Gupta, B. (2015), “India and the great divergence: an Anglo-Indian comparison of GDP per capita, 1600–1871” Explorations in Economic History, 55: 58-75.
  • Iran (Islamic Republic of) — 1820, 1870, 1913, 1950: Pamuk, S. (2006), Estimating Economic Growth in the Middle East since 1820, The Journal of Economic History, vol 66, no. 3, pp. 809 - 828
  • Iraq — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 700 – 1500: Pamuk, Ş. and M. Shatzmiller (2011). “Real Wages and GDP per capita in the Medieval Islamic Middle East in Comparative Perspective, 700-1500”, paper presented at the 9th Conference of the European Historical Economics Society, Dublin, September 2-3, 2011.; 1820, 1870, 1913, 1950: Pamuk, S. (2006), Estimating Economic Growth in the Middle East since 1820, The Journal of Economic History, vol 66, no. 3, pp. 809 - 828
  • Iceland — 1870-1945: Jonsson, G. (1998). The gross domestic product of Iceland, 1870-1945. Nordiska Historiska Nasjonalregnkaper, Artikkelsamling from Workshop IV, Solstrand 13-15 NOvember 1998.
  • Israel — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91
  • Italy — 1451-1861: Chilosi, D., & Ciccarelli, C. (2023). Italy in the Great Divergence: What Can We Learn from Engel’s Law (SSRN Scholarly Paper 4514091).; 1861-1871 (North Italy): Malanima, P. (2010), “The long decline of a leading economy: GDP in central and northern Italy, 1300–1913” European Review of Economic History 15 (2): 169–219.; 1871-1990: Baffigi, A. (2011).”Italian National Accounts, 1861-2011”, Banca d’Italia Economic History Working Papers 18.
  • Jamaica — 1850 - 1938: Prados de la Escosura, L. (2009). “Lost Decades? Economic Performance in Post-Independence Latin America,” Journal of Latin America Studies 41: 279–307 (updated data)
  • Jordan — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 1820, 1870, 1913, 1950: Pamuk, S. (2006), Estimating Economic Growth in the Middle East since 1820, The Journal of Economic History, vol 66, no. 3, pp. 809 - 828
  • Japan — 724-1874: Bassino, Jean-Pascal & Broadberry, Stephen & Fukao, Kyoji & Gupta, Bishnupriya & Takashima, Masanori, (2018). "Japan and the Great Divergence, 730-1874," CEI Working Paper Series 2018-13, Center for Economic Institutions, Institute of Economic Research, Hitotsubashi University; 1874-1940: Fukao, K., Bassino, J.-P., Makino, T., Paprzycki, R., Settsu, T., Takashima, M., and Tokui, J. (2015) Regional Inequality and Industrial Structure in Japan: 1874-2008, Tokyo: Maruzen Publishing.
  • Kenya — 1904-1950: Broadberry, S., & Gardner, L. (2022). Economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa, 1885–2008: Evidence from eight countries. Explorations in Economic History, 83, 101424.
  • Republic of Korea — 1911-1990: Cha, M.S., Kim, N.N., Park, K.-J., Park, Y. (Eds.) (2020), Historical Statistics of Korea. Studies in Economic History, New York: Springer Publishing
  • Lebanon — 1820, 1870, 1913, 1950: Pamuk, S. (2006), Estimating Economic Growth in the Middle East since 1820, The Journal of Economic History, vol 66, no. 3, pp. 809 - 828
  • Liberia — 1845-1950: Gardner, L. (2022). Sovereignty without Power: Liberia in the Age of Empires, 1822-1980. Cambridge University Press.
  • Mexico — 1550–1812: Arroyo Abad, L. and J.L. van Zanden (2016), “Growth under Extractive Institutions? Latin American Per Capita GDP in Colonial Times” Journal of Economic History 76(4): 1182–1215.; 1812–1870: Prados de la Escosura, L., (2009), ‘Lost decades? Economic performance in post-independence Latin America’, Journal of Latin America Studies, 41, pp. 279–307. (updated data); 1870-1895: Bértola, L., & Ocampo, J. A. (2012). The Economic Development of Latin America since Independence. Oxford University Press, Table A.2; 1895–2003: Barro, R.J. and J.F. Ursua, (2008). “Macroeconomic Crises since 1870” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Economic Studies Program, The Brookings Institution, vol. 39(1 (Spring), pages 255-350
  • TFYR of Macedonia — 1952-2008: Milanovic (2011). Estimates provided to the Maddison-Project
  • Montenegro — 1952-2008: Milanovic (2011). Estimates provided to the Maddison-Project
  • Malawi — 1904-1950: Broadberry, S., & Gardner, L. (2022). Economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa, 1885–2008: Evidence from eight countries. Explorations in Economic History, 83, 101424.
  • Malaysia — 1900-1939: Nazrin Shah, S. (2017). Charting the Economy: Early 20th Century Malaya and Contemporary Malaysian Contrasts, Oxford University Press
  • Nigeria — 1885-1950: Broadberry, S., & Gardner, L. (2022). Economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa, 1885–2008: Evidence from eight countries. Explorations in Economic History, 83, 101424.
  • Netherlands — 1348–1807 (Holland): Van Zanden, J. L. and van Leeuwen, B. (2012), ‘Persistent but not consistent: the growth of national income in Holland 1347–1807’, Explorations in Economic History, 49 (2012), pp. 119–30.; 1807-1913: Smits, J.P., E. Horlings and J.L. van Zanden (2000). The Measurement of Gross National Product and its Components 1800-1913 (Groningen Growth and Development Centre Monograph series no 5).
  • Norway — 1820–1930: Grytten, O.H. (2015). Norwegian gross domestic product by industry 1830 - 1930, Norges Bank Working paper 19/2015. Population from Maddison (2006)
  • Panama — 1906–1945: De Corso, G. (2013). El crecimiento economico de Venuzuela, Desde la Oligarquia Conservadora Hasta La Revolucion Bolivariana: 1830-2012. Uno Vision cuantitativa *: Venezuelan Economic Growth From The Conservative Oligarchy To The Bolivarian Revolution (1830-2012), Revista De Historia Económica / Journal of Iberian and Latin American Economic History, 31(3), 321-357. doi:10.1017/S0212610913000190
  • Peru — 1600–1812: Arroyo Abad, L. and J.L. van Zanden (2016), “Growth under Extractive Institutions? Latin American Per Capita GDP in Colonial Times” Journal of Economic History 76(4): 1182–1215.; 1812–1870: Seminario, B. (2015). El Desarrallo de la Economía Peruana en la Era Moderna, Universidad de Pacifico, Lima; 1870-1901: Bertola, L and Ocampo, J.A. (2012) The Economic Development of Latin America since Independence. Oxford, Oxford U.P, Table A2
  • Poland — 1409–1913: Malinowski, M. and Van Zanden (2017), “National income and its distribution in preindustrial Poland in a global perspective” Cliometrica, Volume 11, Issue 3, pp 375–40
  • D.P.R. of Korea — 1911-1940: Cha, M.S., Kim, N.N., Park, K.-J., Park, Y. (Eds.) (2020), Historical Statistics of Korea. Studies in Economic History, New York: Springer Publishing.; 1990-2011: Cha, M.S., Kim, N.N., Park, K.-J., Park, Y. (Eds.) (2020), Historical Statistics of Korea. Studies in Economic History, New York: Springer Publishing.
  • Portugal — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 1530–1850: Palma, N., & Reis, J. (2019). From Convergence to Divergence: Portuguese Economic Growth, 1527–1850. The Journal of Economic History, 79(2), 477-506. doi:10.1017/S0022050719000056
  • Romania — 1862–1995: Axenciuc, V. (2012). Produsul intern brut al Romaniei, Vol. 1, Institutl de Economie Nationala, Bucarest; 1915-1919 & 1949: Voinea, L., Cojocaru, A., Costache, B., Grigoraș, V., Lovin, H., Neagu, C., Orțan, D., & Tănase, A. (2019). One Hundred Years of Honesty: Recovering the Lost Memory of the Romanian Economy 1918-2018.
  • Russia — 1860-1885: Kuboniwa, M. (2019). Estimating GDP and Foreign Rents of the Oil and Gas Sector in the Soviet Union and Present-Day Russia. In M. Kuboniwa, Y. Nakamura, K. Kumo, & Y. Shida (Eds.), Russian Economic Development over Three Centuries: New Data and Inferences (pp. 421–438). Springer.
  • Saudi Arabia — 1820, 1870, 1913, 1950: Pamuk, S. (2006), Estimating Economic Growth in the Middle East since 1820, The Journal of Economic History, vol 66, no. 3, pp. 809 - 828
  • Singapore — 1900–1959: Sugimoto, I. (2011), Economic growth of Singapore in the twentieth century: historical GDP estimates and empirical investigations, Economic Growth Centre Research Monograph ser., 2, http://www.worldscibooks.com/economics/7858.html (accessed on 30 Jan. 2013).
  • Serbia — 1952-2008: Milanovic (2011). Estimates provided to the Maddison-Project
  • Former USSR — 1860-1885: Kuboniwa, M. (2019). Estimating GDP and Foreign Rents of the Oil and Gas Sector in the Soviet Union and Present-Day Russia. In M. Kuboniwa, Y. Nakamura, K. Kumo, & Y. Shida (Eds.), Russian Economic Development over Three Centuries: New Data and Inferences (pp. 421–438). Springer.; 1885-1913: Gregory, P. R. (1982). Russian National Income, 1885–1913, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1913-1928: Markevich, A. and M. Harrison (2011). “Great War, Civil War, and Recovery: Russia's National Income, 1913 to 1928”, The Journal of Economic History, Volume 71 (3): 672 – 703, table 6.; 1991 -: Based on GDP and population data for their successor states
  • Slovenia — 1952-2008: Milanovic (2011). Estimates provided to the Maddison-Project
  • Sweden — 1300–1560: Krantz, O. (2017) “Swedish GDP 1300-1560 A Tentative Estimate” Lund Papers in Economic History: General Issues; No. 152.; 1560–1950: Schön, L., and O. Krantz (2015) “New Swedish Historical National Accounts since the 16th Century in Constant and Current Prices” Lund Papers in Economic History no. 140
  • Syrian Arab Republic — 1820, 1870, 1913, 1950: Pamuk, S. (2006), Estimating Economic Growth in the Middle East since 1820, The Journal of Economic History, vol 66, no. 3, pp. 809 - 828
  • Turkey — 1: Scheidel, W. and Friesen, S. J., ‘The size of the economy and the distribution of income in the Roman Empire’, Journal of Roman Studies, 99 (2009), pp. 61–91; 700 - 1820: Pamuk, Ş. and M. Shatzmiller (2011). “Real Wages and GDP per capita in the Medieval Islamic Middle East in Comparative Perspective, 700-1500”, paper presented at the 9th Conference of the European Historical Economics Society, Dublin, September 2-3, 2011; Milanovic, B. (2006), “An estimate of average income and inequality in Byzantium around year 1000,” Review of Income and Wealth 52 (3).; 1500-1820: Pamuk, S. (2009). “Estimating GDP per capita for the Ottoman Empire in a European Comparative Framework, 1500-1820”, paper presented at the XVth World Economic History Congress, August 2009, Utrecht
  • Taiwan, Province of China — 1820 - 1940: Fukao, K., D. Ma and T. Yuan (2007). Real GDP in Pre-War East Asia: A 1934-36 Benchmark Purchasing Power Parity Comparison with the U.S. Review of Income and Wealth, 53 (3): 503 - 537. Trend from original Maddison estimates applied to benchmark for 1934/36
  • Uganda — 1906-1950: Broadberry, S., & Gardner, L. (2022). Economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa, 1885–2008: Evidence from eight countries. Explorations in Economic History, 83, 101424.
  • Uruguay — 1800-1870: Prados de la Escosura, L. (2009). “Lost Decades? Economic Performance in Post-Independence Latin America,” Journal of Latin America Studies 41: 279–307. (updated data); 1870–2014: Bèrtola, L. (2016). El PIB per Capita de Uruguay 1870 - 2016: una reconstruccion. PHES working paper No 48
  • United States — 1650 - 1790: McCusker, John J., ‘Colonial Statistics’, Historical Statistics of the United States: Earliest Time to the Present, in S. B. Carter, S. S. Gartner, M. R. Haineset al. New York, Cambridge University Press. V-671.; 1790 - 1870: Sutch, R. (2006). National Income and Product. Historical Statistics of the United States: Earliest Time to the Present, in S. B. Carter, S. S. Gartner, M. R. Haineset al. New York, Cambridge University Press III-23-25.; 1800-1830: Prados de la Escosura, L. (2009). “Lost Decades? Economic Performance in Post-Independence Latin America,” Journal of Latin America Studies 41: 279–307. (updated data)
  • Venezuela (Bolivarian Republic of) — 1830–2012: De Corso, G. (2013). El crecimiento economico de Venuzuela, Desde la Oligarquia Conservadora Hasta La Revolucion Bolivariana: 1830-2012. Uno Vision cuantitativa *: Venezuelan Economic Growth From The Conservative Oligarchy To The Bolivarian Revolution (1830-2012), Revista De Historia Económica / Journal of Iberian and Latin American Economic History, 31(3), 321-357. doi:10.1017/S0212610913000190
  • Former Yugoslavia — 1952-2008: Milanovic (2011). Estimates provided to the Maddison-Project; 2008 -: Based on GDP and population data for their successor states
  • South Africa — 1700–1900 (Cape Colony): Fourie, J. and Van Zanden, J.L. (2013). GDP in the Dutch Cape Colony: the Nationals Accounts of a Slave-Based Society, South African Journal of Economics, vol. 81 (4): 467 - 490
  • Zambia — 1906-1950: Broadberry, S., & Gardner, L. (2022). Economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa, 1885–2008: Evidence from eight countries. Explorations in Economic History, 83, 101424.
  • Zimbabwe — 1914-1950: Broadberry, S., & Gardner, L. (2022). Economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa, 1885–2008: Evidence from eight countries. Explorations in Economic History, 83, 101424.

Angus Maddison的原始来源(2010)

  • Argentina — 1900-1913: Unpublished annual estimates supplied by ECLA/CONADE. and quinquennial averages published in El Desarrollo Económico de la Argentina, ECLA, Mexico, 1959, p. 15;; 1913-1950: IEERAL, "Estadísticas de la evolución económica de Argentina, 1913-84", Estudios, Buenos Aires, July-September, 1986.
  • Australia — 1820-1828: Butlin, N.G. 'Our 200 Years', Queesland Calendar, 1988; 1828-1860: N.G. Butlin, "Contours of the Australian Economy 1788-1860", Australian Economic Review, Sept. 1986, pp. 112-13;; 1861-1938/9: N.G. Butlin, Australian Domestic Product, Investment and Foreign Borrowing 1861-1938/9, Cambridge, 1962,pp.460-1; amdended as indicated in N.G. Butlin, Investment in Australian Economic Development 1861-19000, Cambridge, 1964, p. 453 and with revised deflator shown in M.W. Butlin, A Preliminary Annual Databae 1900/1901 to 1973/1974, Discussion Paper 7701, Reserve Bank of Australia, 1977, p. 41; 1938/9-1950: from expenditure aggregates in 1966/7 prices in M.W. Butlin, RS/FLW/, p.85.
  • Austria — 1830-1913: Kausel, "Oster-reichs Volkseinkommen 1830 bis 1913" in Geschichte und Ergebnisse der zentralen amtlichen Statistik in Österreich 1829-1979, Beitrage zur österreichischen Statistik, Heft 550, Vienna, 1979, pp. 692-3.; 1913-50: A. Kausel, N. Nemeth, and H. Seidel, "Oster-reichs Volkseinkommen, 1913-63", Monatsberichte des Osterreichischen Institutes für Wirtschaftsforschung, 14th Sonderheft, Vienna, August 1965, p. 38 and 42;
  • Belgium — 1846-1913: J. Gadisseur, "Contribution à l'étude de la production agricole en Belgique de 1846 à 1913", Revue belge d'histoire contemporaine, vol. IV, 1-2, 1973,; 1913-1950: C. Carbonnelle, "Recherches sur levolution de la production en Belgique de 1900à 1957", Cahiers Economiques de Bruxelles, no. 3, April 1959, p. 358.
  • Bangladesh — 1900-1950: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995
  • Brazil — 1900-1950: A. Maddison and Associates, The Political Economy of Poverty, Equity and Growth: Brazil and Mexico, Oxford University Press, New York 1992;
  • Canada — 1820-1850: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995; 1851-70: O.J. Firestone, "Canada's Changing Economy in the Second Half of the 19th Century", NBER, New York, 1957, processed, amended for 1820–70 to include income of the indigenous population (taken to be $400 per capita in 1820 and 1870); 1870-1926: M.C. Urquart and Associates, ed., Gross National Product, Canada 1870-1926: The Derivation of the Estimates, McGill Queen's University Press, Montreal, 1993, pp. 11-12 and 24-5,; 1926-1950: Statistics Canada, National Income and Expenditure Accounts, vol. 1, The Annual Estimates 1926-1974, Ottawa, 1975, p. 323. 1960 onwards from OECD, National Accounts.
  • Colombia — 1929 - 1950: CEPAL, Series Historicas del Crecimiento de America Latina, Santiago, 1978
  • Czechoslovakia — 1820-1913: A. Kausel, "Österreichs Volkseinkommen 1830 bis 1913", in "Geschichte und Ergebnisse der zentralen amtlichen Statistik in Österreich 1829-1979", Beiträge zum Osterreichischen Statistik, 550, Vienna, 1979.; 1913-37: F.L. Pryor, Z.P. Pryor, M. Stadnik, and G.J. Staller "Czechoslovakia Aggregate Production in the Inter-war Period", Review of Income and Wealth, March 1971, p.36.; 1937-50: G. Lazarcik, "Czechoslovak Gross National Product by Sector of Origin and Final Use, 1937, and 1948-65"", Occasional Paper 26, Research Project on National Income in East Central Europe, New York, 1969.
  • Denmark — 1820-1947: S.A. Hansen, Okonomisk vaekst i Danmark, vol. II, Institute of Economic History, Copenhagen, 1974, pp. 229-32; 1947-50: Soren Larsen, "Reviderede tidsserier for produktionsvaerdi og bruttofaktorindkomst for perioden 1947- 65", CBS, Copenhagen, 1992, mimeographed.
  • Germany — 1850-1950: Hoffmann, Grumbach and Hesse, op. cit., pp. 454-5.
  • Finland — 1860-1960: R. Hjerppe, The Finnish Economy 1860-1985: Growth and Structural Change, Bank of Finland, Helsinki, 1989, pp. 198-200.
  • France — 1850-1913: Toutain, Le Produit interieur de la France de 1789 a 1982, Presses Universitaires de Grenoble, 1987; 1920-1950: Toutain, Le Produit interieur de la France de 1789 a 1982, Presses Universitaires de Grenoble, 1987
  • United Kingdom — 1870-1950: C.H. Feinstein, National Income Expenditure and Output of the United Kingdom 1855-1965, Cambridge, 1972
  • Greece — 1913-1929: C. Clark, Conditions of Economic Progress, 3rd edition, Macmillan, London, 1957; 1929-38 GNP at factor cost from Ekonomikos Tachydromos, 22 May 1954; 1938-50 from OEEC, Europe and the World Economy, Paris 1960, p.116.; 1929-1950: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995
  • Hungary — 1870-1913: L. Katus, "Economic Growth in Hungary during the Age of Dualism (1867-1913)" in E. Pemlenyi, ed., Social Economic Research in the History of East Central Europe, Akademiai Kiado, Budapest, 1970, p.108 and J. Komlos, The Habsburg Monarchy as a Customs Union, Princeton, 1983, pp. 291-3; 1900-42: A. Eckstein, "National Income and Capital Formation in Hungary, 1900-50", in S. Kuznets, ed., Income and Wealth, series V GNP index, Bowes and Bowes, London, 1955, p. 175; 1938-50: from L. Czirjak, "Hungarian GNP by Sectors of Origin of Product and End Uses, 1938 and 1946-67", Occasional Paper 43, Research Project on East Central Europe, New York, 1973.
  • India — 1870-1900: A. Heston, "National Income", in D. Kumar and M. Desai, Cambridge Economic History of India, vol. 2, Cambridge, 1983, p. 397.; 1900-46: A. Maddison, "Alternative Estimates of the Real Product of India, 1900-46", Indian Economic and Social History Review, 22, 2, 1985.; 1946-50: A. Maddison, Class Structure and Economic Growth: India and Pakistan Since the Moghuls, Allen and Unwin, London, 1971, p. 169.
  • Ireland — 1820, 1870, 1913: MPD 2013, Bolt and Van Zanden, 2014, The Maddison Project: collaborative research on historical national accounts. The Economic History Review, 67(3), 627–651; 1913-1926: P. Deane (1968), and Feinstein, 1972; 1926-1950: K.A. Kennedy, Productivity and Industrial Growth: The Irish Experience, Oxford University Press, 1971, p. 3.
  • Republic of Korea — 1820, 1870: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995
  • Myanmar — 1901-1938: "Trends of Economic Growth and Income Distribution in Burma 1870-1940", Journal of the Burma Research Society, 1964, p. 144; 1938-1950: E.E. Hagen, On the Theory of Social Change, Dorsey, Homewood, Illinois, 1962, Table 18-1,
  • Netherlands — 1913-1950: C.A. van Bochove and T.A. Huitker, "Main National Accounting Series, 1900-1986", CBS Occasional Paper, No. 17, The Hague, 1987.
  • Norway — 1930-1950: Central Bureau of Statistics Norway, 1970 and Maddison, A. Monintoring the World Economy, 1995
  • New Zealand: — 1870-1939: K. Rankin, "New Zealand's Gross National Product: 1859-1939, Review of Income and Wealth, March 1992, pp. 60-1., 1870 amended to include indigenous population (taken to be $400 per capita); 1939-50: C. Clark, The Conditions of Economic Progress, third edition, Macmillan, London, 1957, pp. 171-2
  • Peru — 1900-1913: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995; 1913-1941: C.A. Bolona Behr, "Tariff Policies in Peru, 1880-1980", Ph.D. thesis, Oxford University, 1981;; 1942-1950: "Cuadros del producto interno bruto en dollares de 1950", CEPAL, Santiago, October 1962, mimeographed;; 1945-1950: Series Historicas del Crecimiento de America Latina, CEPAL, Santiago, 1978.
  • Philippines — 1820-1900: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995; 1900-1950: R.W. Hooley, "Long Term Growth of the Philippine Economy, 1902-1961", , The Philippine Economic Journal, First Semester, 1968.
  • Poland — 1913-1929: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995; 1929-1938: K. Laski, Akumulacja i spozycie w procesie uprzemyslowienia Polski Ludowej, Ksiazka i Wiedza, Warsaw, 1956, pp. 86-90; 1937-1950: T.P. Alton (1970), p. 46,
  • Portugal — 1850-1913: Pedro Lains, "How Far Can We Go? Measuring Portuguese Economic Growth (1850-1913)"; 1938-1950: R. Janes Cartado and N.E. Sequeira da Rosa, Series Longas as Contas Nacionais Portuguesas 1958-1985, Banco de Portugal, Lisbon,
  • Former USSR — 1928-40: R. Moorsteen and R.P. Powell, The Soviet Capital Stock 1928-1962, Irwin, Illinois, 1966, p. 361; 1945-50: R. Moorsteen and R.P. Powell, The Soviet Capital Stock 1928-1962, Irwin, Illinois, 1966, p. 362; 1950-90: CIA
  • Thailand — 1820-1900: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995; 1900-50: Sompop Manarungsan, "Economic Development of Thailand, 1850-1950", University of Groningen, Ph. D. thesis, 1989
  • Turkey — 182, 1870: Maddison, A. Monitoring the World Economy, 1995; 1923-48: T. Bulutay, Y.S. Tezel and N. Yielderim, Turkiye Milli Geliri 1923-1948, Ankara, 1974.
  • United States — 1820-1950: GDP movement from Maddison (1995a), amended for 1820–70 to include income of the indigenous population (taken to be $400 per capita in 1820 and 1870).
  • Former Yugoslavia — 1870-1909: Maddison, A. The World Economy, a Millenial Perspective, OECD, 2001; 1909-12: I. Vinski, "National Product and Fixed Assets in the Territory of Yugoslavia 1900-59" , in P. Deane, ed., Income and Wealth, Series IX, Bowes and Bowes, London, 1961, p. 221; 1920-39: I. Vinski, "National Product and Fixed Assets in the Territory of Yugoslavia 1900-59" , in P. Deane, ed., Income and Wealth, Series IX, Bowes and Bowes, London, 1961, p. 222; 1947-52: I. Vinski, "National Product and Fixed Assets in the Territory of Yugoslavia 1900-59" , in P. Deane, ed., Income and Wealth, Series IX, Bowes and Bowes, London, 1961, p. 223

转载本文

文字和图表可在 CC BY 4.0 下自由转载、翻译和改编:请署名 BigCapital.org 并附上本页链接。其他提供方的数据保留各自的许可协议(见下方来源)。如何署名

来源:BigCapital.org —“民主与经济增长”,https://bigcapital.org/zh/articles/democracy-and-economic-growth/

语言

EnglishBahasa IndonesiaDeutschEspañolFrançaisItalianoNederlandsPolskiPortuguêsTürkçeРусскийУкраїнська日本語한국어简体中文